Saturday, February 26, 2011

Thinking About Our Thoughts: The Mind-Brain Distinction

I've lately been reading James LeFanu's Why Us? How Science Rediscovered the Mystery of Ourselves. LeFanu is a British medical doctor and science journalist who doesn't buy the materialist line that we are merely biological machines programmed by our genes and running on chemical reactions in the brain. My college philosophy professor argued that the mind is an allusion. The brain is all. Thought is nothing more than biochemical reactions in the brain. He pointed out that scientists can see the brain lighting up as they process information from the sense. I was stumped or should I say my chemical reactions were curbed.

LeFanu points our that we don't experience the world like a machine, but as a self. We don't just process sense impressions, but we tell ourselves what to think and how to think. This is how we "take every thought captive" (2 Cor, 10:5) and overcome disorders like OCD. The brain doesn't work like a computer storing information and pulling it up out of digital files.

The brain constructs the world we experience from neurons bombarding our senses. That world of color, sound, smell, taste, and touch comes from the impact of colorless, mute, odorless, tasteless, and intangible neurons. Our brains translate the interaction into a lively world for the self to navigate. The self presides over all this by giving attention to certain impressions, thinking about them, and then "presumably" storing those thoughts somewhere in the brain.

Using brain scans, cognitive scientists have show that the brain memorizes in one part but recalls that memory from another part. So where was the memory stored and how can it be conjured up decades later from a part of the brain that was not lighting up during the act of memory creation? This has baffled researchers.

There is a qualitative difference between computation and consciousness. Ever increasing levels of programming and computation by ludicrous speed computers will only ever be able to simulate consciousness.

The optic nerve doesn't simply photograph an image from the outside world but creates the images of  world outside. Lefanu says, "The brain perceives the world 'out there' by fragmenting the visual image into thirty separate specialized 'maps' scattered throughout the visual cortex ... arranged in a hierarchy of fourteen different levels" (202-03). One map might clarify what it is, say a cat, by noting its color, shape, and size. Another map might tell where it is located, say in a tree. If the cat is moving, say from the limb above to the earth below, the brain has to repeat this process moment by moment. Since the cat is never the same as it twists through the air in order to land on its feet, the brain must continually be able to categorize it as a cat.

"Attributes such as form, colour, and movement" are "handled by separate structures of the brain" but how is it all assembled into the same image and categorized by the brain? One scientist says, "It obviously must be assembled, but where and how, we have no idea" (206). It must also associate the images of the cat with mewing or in this case screeching received by the auditory nerve. It seems the brain is hardwired to know the world. It must "be born with an innate knowledge of how the world works." It seems that Descartes was correct about us being born with innate ideas. The linguist Noam Chomsky asserted that children must be born with a "'language acquisition device', ... by which they could make sense of the babble of sounds around them" (189).

It turns out that the brain has billions of neurons and creates trillions of synapses and can do upwards of a quadrillion computations per second. We don't just have the equivalent of one supercomputer in our heads that will soon be surpassed in our cyborg future. Charles Jonscher, a computer scientist from Harvard says, "The true comparison would be a figure more like twenty billion computers" (187). Daniel Levitin, the author of This Is Your Brain on Music, has speculated that there are more states of mind possible than there are atoms in the known universe.

All this begs the question of how we know that the rich experience of the outside world of cats and trees and mountains and oceans is true. If it is subjectively created by the brain from interactions with subatomic particles, then how do we know it is a reliable representation of the objective world outside ourselves. How can we trust our senses? How can we believe our eyes and ears?

Lefanu doesn't go there, but the only basis for confidence in the senses is the Christian doctrine of creation. Our senses can reliably know the world we experience, if and only if they were created to know that world by a loving creator who made both to correspond. I suppose that one could say that we know it is true because it is successful. But that begs the question of why we would find success between two separately evolving systems? G. K. Chesterton wrote:
Reason itself is a matter of faith. It is an act of faith to assert that our thoughts have any relation to reality at all. If you are merely a skeptic, you must sooner or later ask yourself the question, "Why should anything go right; even observation and deduction? Why should not good logic be as misleading as bad logic? They are both movements in the brain of a bewildered ape?" The young skeptic says, "I have a right to think for myself." But the old skeptic, the complete skeptic, says, "I have no right to think for myself. I have no right to think at all." There is a thought that stops thought (Orthodoxy, Chap. 3).
Materialism is self-defeating and cannot explain something as basic as self consciousness. The mind cannot be reduced to the brain without calling self consciousness an illusion. A brain thinks but the mind tells it how. With all of our intelligent design capabilities we can only mimic the self with our "artificial" intelligences. Even if we could create self-conscious beings like ourselves would it disprove intelligent design? Not unless we are sub-intelligent.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

How the Pioneers Felt

My wife found one of the funniest things I've heard in awhile on Facebook. It was the status of one of friends Ruth Akers.


My cable is out so I can't watch TV on the big screen and I'm forced to use my iPhone as a tether to watch Netflix on my iPad. 
Now I know how the pioneers felt. 
This strikes us as funny because we think we have it hard sometimes. But when we compare our place in history to any other place in history, we realize that we have comforts and capabilities that nobody could've imagined fifty years ago. I only pray that we will use them wisely, even when the cable goes out.

Plot and Character

PoeticsPoetics by Aristotle
My rating: 4 of 5 stars


Aristotle says that the exercise of any capacity brings pleasure. He defines poetry as language made pleasurable in verse form. Aristotle distinguishes the poetic genres of epic poetry (like Homer's Illiad and Odyssey) and tragedy (like the plays of Aeschylus and Sophocles) and comedy (like the plays of Aristophanes). Aristotle only mentions lyric poetry, which is what we normally think of as poetry (like a sonnet). When Aristotle is talking about poetics, we should think of stories in verse form like Shakespeare's plays.

Aristotle explains that we enjoy poetics because of their imitation (mimesis) of reality. Thus Aristotle doesn't believe that our enjoyment of good poetry is purely subjective or only a matter of taste. The better the imitation of reality and the more pleasurable the language, the more our enjoyment will increase. I suppose that the subjective element is our own version of reality, which dictates whether we agree with the author's vision of reality. While Aristotle might have conceded this, he focuses on standards for imitation and pleasurable language.

Comedy is "an imitation of inferior people.... The laughable is an error or disgrace that does not involve pain or destruction" (3.4). When we laugh we recognize something ridiculous in others. Hopefully we can do this when we recognize our own silliness, but Aristotle doesn't "go there." Epic poetry, on the other hand, "is an imitation in verse of admirable people," like the hero Odysseus. "Tragedy is an imitation of an action that is admirable, complete and possesses magnitude ... effecting through pity and fear the purification (katharsis) of such emotion" (4.1). Thus we come to one of the main differences between Aristotle and Plato.

Plato criticized the poets in Book Ten of Republic, because he considered their work a mere representation of reality, which also stirred up the emotions. Plato considered reason the highest human faculty, whose job it was to tame the passions of the heart and discipline the appetites of the body. Thus poets were guilty of creating escapist fiction. Conversely, in his Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle wrote:

For example, fear, confidence, desire, anger, pity and in general pleasure and distress can be experienced in greater or lesser degree, and in both cases wrongly. To feel them at the right time, in response to the right things, with regard to the right people, for the right reason and in the right way--that is the mean and optimum, which is the characteristic of virtue (1106b.18-23; cited in Introduction xxxviii).

According to Aristotle, the emotions weren't necessarily inferior to reason. They merely needed to be exercised and trained, just like reason. This happened during katharsis or "purification" by experiencing emotion through tragic stories. Thus if tragedies could release and train the emotions in a positive way, we need quality stories with good plots. A good plot imitates reality accurately and presents characters that we can recognize.

A defective plot was one in which "the sequence of episodes is neither necessary nor probable.... they draw out the plot beyond its potential" (5.6). We tend not to love books or movies whose plots or actions are not believable or inaccurate. But we must also take into account the genre of the story. We wouldn't expect the driver in "Driving Miss Daisy" to suddenly put on a wizard's hat and wave a staff to avoid a car accident, but such actions in a fantasy story would not be unrealistic.

Good plots, for Aristotle, create astonishment through reversal, recognition, and suffering. Aristotle cites Sophocles' "Oedipus Rex," as an example. At the end of the play, when understanding dawns and the great king falls, the reader is amazed. A modern example would be the movie "The Sixth Sense," in which a reversal occurs at the end of the action. We then “recognize” what’s really going on and are surprised to find that we have been watching the movie the wrong way from the beginning.

The goal of character is goodness, appropriateness, likeness, and consistency. This means that characters, once established, must not act out of character. Concerning goodness, Aristotle says, "The character is good if the choice is good" (8.1). In the movie “Shadowlands,” the following words are put into the mouth of C. S. Lewis: "Aristotle’s solution was simple and radical, plot is character. Forget psychology; forget the insides of men’s heads. Judge them by their actions." This insight into Aristotle is in sharp contrast to our post-modern movies, which often try to reconstruct villains by creating sympathy for them.

From a Christian point of view, sympathy for a bad character is sinister, unless it creates a desire to redeem the bad character. This happens in Lord of the Rings with Gollum, when we are given a peek into his background. As Frodo begins the "taming of Smeagol [Gollum]," we begin to feel pity for him Gollum and hope that he can change. There are examples in the Bible like Jacob's brothers, but the norm in Scripture is bad guys are bad guys, and they will be judged by their actions. God will call us all to account, and good plots do the same, rather than making excuses for badness or trying to create sympathy toward sin.

Also contrary to Hollywood is Aristotle's dictum "no unnecessary badness" (8.1). The gratuitous, the explicit, and the shocking pass for realism today instead of the true, the good, and the beautiful. There are endless examples of this in recent movies and books. Aristotle provides some from the ancient world, and they are quite tame in comparison to our own. An example of a terrible villain who isn't “unnecessarily badæ is Kevin Bacon's character in "The River Wild." I think he says about two cuss words in the whole movie and there is little to no sexual innuendo. Oh, to read and watch without feeling the need afterwards to take a bath!

Aristotle also discusses poetic style:

The most important quality in diction is clarity, provided there is no loss of dignity. The clearest diction is that based on current words; but that lacks dignity. By contrast, diction is distinguished and out of the ordinary when it makes use of exotic expressions -- by which I mean non-standard words, metaphors, lengthening, and anything contrary to current usage.... So what is needed is some kind of mixture of these two things: one of them will make the diction out of the ordinary and avoid a loss of dignity ... while current usage will contribute clarity (9.4).

Aristotle gives plenty of examples to illustrate his points and Homer is praised beyond the rest as "he excels everyone in diction and reasoning" (10.2). Constructing quality plots is not easy but Aristotle advises: "nature itself teaches people to choose what is appropriate to it" (10.3). Nature, not artifice, is the standard for Aristotle.

Aristotle also addressed strict imitation vs. poetic license: "Impossibilities should be referred to poetic effect, or idealization of the truth, or opinion. With regard to poetic effect, a plausible impossibility is preferable to what is implausible but possible.... It is probable that improbable things will happen" (11.3). When we think of or experience an improbability, we might have the basis for an interesting plot. I'm afraid that many moviemakers today start with special effects they want to create, and a screenplay is concocted artificially to present it. A return to Aristotle would mean a much needed return to plot and character.


View all my reviews

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

What We Should Already Know

G. K. Chesterton wrote:
The cinema boasts of being a substitute for the tavern, but I think it a very bad substitute. I think so quite apart from the question of fermented liquor. Nobody enjoys cinema more than I, but to enjoy them a man has only to look and not even to listen and in a tavern he has to talk. Occasionally, I admit, he has to fight; but he never need move at the movies (What I Saw in America, 102).
Current research supports the common sense notion that reading, learning languages, and social interaction improves memory function and prevents cognitive decline. It also shows that watching TV reduces memory function and contributes to decline in both the young and old ("Maintaing Your Mental Edge," Lecture 29 in "Lifelong Health: Achieving Optimum Well-Being at Any Age," The Great Courses [The Teaching Company, 2010]).

Why don't we make common sense a little more common? Then perhaps we won't spend millions funding research to demonstrate what we should already know. We can knock off early and go to the tavern. Maybe instead of a fist fight, a verbal brawl, in Christian love of course, might do us some good. Even taking in the occasional movie might prove a good field for battle.

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Economics to the Glory of God Pt. 2

Proverbs 28:8

Whoever multiples his wealth by
interest and profit
gathers it for him who is 
generous to the poor.

According to God's economy tithes, offerings, and giving to the poor is simply the best investment. Savings is second and Wall Street is much further down the list. This shows just how screwed up we've become.

Proverbs 28: 19-22, 26-27
Whoever works his land will have plenty of bread,
but he who follows worthless pursuits will have plenty of poverty.

A faithful man will abound with blessings,
but whoever hastens to be rich will not go unpunished.

To show partiality is not good, 
but for a piece of bread a man will do wrong.

A stingy man hastens after wealth
and does not know that poverty will come upon him....

Whoever trusts in his own mind is a fool,
but he who walks in wisdom will be delivered.

Whoever gives to the poor will not want, 
but he who hides his eyes will get many a curse.

Are we working our land and giving to the poor? That is a perennial question in Scripture. Whether we are diversified is also important, but doesn't receive the same emphasis.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Nominal Nominations

After seeing "The King's Speech" last night I would like to go ahead with my Oscar nominations:


Movie of the Year:

  • "The Kings Speech" (compelling)
  • "Nanny McPhee Returns" (Inspirational)
  • "True Grit" (Grisled Realism, except the rattle snakes)
  • "Despicable Me" (Redemptive)
  • "Inception" (Dreamy)


Best Actor:

  • The young girl in "True Grit" 
  • Colin Firth "The Kings Speech" 


Best Supporting Actor:

  • Geoffrey Rush "The Kings Speech" 
  • Jeff Bridges "True Grit"


Special Effects:

  • "Inception"
  • "Voyage of the Dawn Treader"
  • "Tron Legacy"

Screen Play:
  • "Inception"
  • "The Kings Speech"


Worst Hack Job:

  • "Gulliver's Travels"
  • "The Actual Nominations of the Academy"

Saturday, January 22, 2011

Economics to the Glory of God

Proverbs 22:16
Whoever oppresses the poor to 
increase his own wealth,
or gives to the rich, will only
come to poverty.
We have had our share of economic woes lately in America. Could they be related to the truth of that verse? The rich have been getting richer and the poor poorer for a long time. In the 1970's a CEO was paid twenty times more than the lowest paid worker. Today he's paid over 300 times more (Goodzward, Hope in Troubled Times)!

The Mondragon Corporation in Spain is based on Distributist principles so that the highest paid is remunerated at only six times more than the lowest paid worker. It is a billion dollar company (William Cavanaugh, Being Consumed).

When will we learn to love our neighbor as ourselves?

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Republic of Thought

Plato: RepublicPlato: Republic by Robin Waterfield
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This was my second dip, and this time I swam from one end to the other and read almost all of Waterfield's notes. There are things to be said about Plato and about Waterfield as a translator and commentator. Plato first.

The republic is an empire of thought. Plato knows that it is a mere thought experiment and that it will never take. That said "Ideas have consequences" and Plato certainly tries to make his mark on political, philosophical, and theological policy. What is refreshing about this ancient air that blows off every page is that Plato's goal is to convince that in order to have an orderly civil order laws and behavior must be grounded in the absolute or what he calls "the Form of the Good." In the argument between the Christian and the secularist Plato is firmly in the camp of the Christian. He knows that a robust morality cannot be brewed from the grounds of "enlightened self-interest."  Enlightened self-interest is like the shifting shadows on the "cave" wall - just "shadows of morality" (517.d). There must be an absolute standard to even distinguish good and evil, much less be able to legislate it for a community. Today we expect morality to spontaneously generate apart from moral authority. Plato argued that the Form of the Good not only casts light for the mind's eye to see all of reality but it was the source of all reality and thus everything good. It is even the source of 2 + 2 = 4, so that it would actually be immoral to teach that 2 + 2 = 5. We can't have morality on any other terms but a knowledge of God, whom he called the One, and his true Ideas. Plato wrote:

"It isn't only the known-ness of the things we know which is conferred upon them by goodness, but also their reaity and their being .... It's my opinion that the last thing to be seen -- and it isn't easy to see either--in the realm of knowledge is goodness; and the sight of the character of goodness leads one to deduce that it is responsible for everything that is right and fine, whatever the circumstances, and that in the visible realm it is the progenitor of light and of the source of light, and in the intelligible realm it is the source and provider of truth and knowledge. And I also think that the sight of it is a prerequisite for intelligent conduct either of one's own private affairs or of public business" (509b, 517c).

It's true that Plato was an elitist, dividing society into the castes of guardians, who are philosopher kings, auxiliaries, who oversee the military, and workers who farm, build, buy, and sell. He believed that the guardians must be given an education in what T. S. Eliot called the "permanent things:

"Imagine someone who really lacks the ability to recognize any and every real thing and has no paradigm to shed light for the mind's eye. He has nothing absolutely authentic to contemplate ... and use as a reference-point whenever he needs to, and gain a completely accurate picture of, before establishing human norms of right, morality, and goodness (if establishing is what is required), and before guarding and protecting the norms that have already been established."

This means that those who govern need an absolute standard or transcendent basis for law. Laws must transcend individuals if they are to bind all individuals and thus whole communities. Are we the first civilization, where most of the elites think we can dispence with the transcendent and still have a moral order? Every time someone declares someone else in the wrong he assumes something binds them both. Where does he get this moral authority over other people?

Plato has his problems as well. He would like for the government of the philosopher kings to take over the role of the family and all children to call older men father so that the family fades into the larger community. The Philosophers are to arrange marriages of the best and brightest of both classes in order to improve the race and men are to share the women and have multiple marriages. The Philosophers are to tell everyone the noble lie that some are made of gold and meant to govern, while others are silver, and the rest are copper and iron and meant for manual labor. But all are rational enough to accept this as corresponding to their nature and thus good for them. Plato would abolish private property and personal possessions among the guardians in order to get rid of envy and ambition. The workers are allowed to own and possess and thus they might not be jealous of the guardians unless they were rational and wanted to rule for the right reasons. These could be recognized and moved up to the philosopher class and others could be demoted if they weren't interested in philosophy.

From a Christian point of view Plato is still playing with the "shadows of morality" since he doesn't know God's special revelation, but he does better than most with general revelation. It's not until we read the best of the ancient world that we realize what an effect Christianity has had on the West and just how much of our morality that we take for granted as rational, such as marital fidelity and equality of women and children, was actually revealed by the God of the Bible.

Now on to our translator Robin Waterfield. Waterfield doesn't go with the traditional translation of "eidos" as "form" but uses "type" instead. For some reason modern translators can't leave well enough alone and go for worse. The type of the good doesn't have the same force as the "form" of the good. On top of this Waterfield is a materialist who can't understand Plato at points.

Plato apparantly stands out in Greece for believing in the minds immortality. He argues that a things disease always destroys it like when rust reduces metal to dust. The mind must be immortal however because its disease, which is immorality, doesn't destroy it. In fact most, like an early character named Thrasymachus, become clever and vivacious in their promotion of immorality. Waterfield calls Plato's argument circular and here's why:

"There is no reason to suppose that physical death and psychic death are not identical, or that what destroys bodies does not also destroy minds, unless one already believes that the mind is different in substance from the body."

If the mind is reducible to the brain, which is grey matter and chemicals, then explain self-consciousness. Computers aren't self-conscious. If all we have is nerves and synapsis then how are we able to tell ourselves how and what to think? Explain the longing for transcendent meaning in this bag of chemicals that we call man. There's no reason to suppose that our minds die when our brain function stops unless one already "believes" that the mind is reducible to the brain.

In another place Plato says, "It's goodness which gives the things we know their truth and makes it possible for people to have knowledge." Waterfield says, "what is the meaning of the assertion that goodness is responsible for truth and knowledge? (Truth means little ore than just knowability here) .... It cannot be merely that to know a thing is to know in what way it is good, because Plato envisages knowable types of immorality and evil." Why can't Plato be saying that knowledge of the good is the source of our knowledge of all things and even our knowledge of bad things because the bad things are a perversion of the formerly good thing. Knowledge of the good means we know 2 + 2 = 4, and we know that it would actually be immoral to teach that 2 + 2 = 5.

That said Waterman's translation is a good read and his notes are certainly more than worthwhile.




View all my reviews

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Luxury Folly

I just re-listened to a Mars Hill Audio interview with Robert Frank about his 1999 book Luxury Fever: Money and Happiness in an Era Excess. It has been republished in 2010 by Princeton Univ. Press, because it is probably more relevant than ever.

Frank argues that we buy possessions that don't make us happy, because the incentives are wrong. Our consumer culture sends us the message that to be successful we must look the part. This means conspicuous consumption like the Lexus, the sprawling estate, and the flashy wardrobe with all the accessories. Inconspicuous consumption like vacation, family time, and relaxation, which we know are more fulfilling, are not incentivized by our consumer economy.

Thus Frank proposes a economic model that sounds more like what my grandparents knew. I've always wondered why during WWII the war effort at home was always about sacrifice and doing without. Today we're told that if we want to help, we need to get out and spend. We chart consumer confidence as a mark of a healthy economy. It's spending not savings, stupid!

Frank says not so fast. If we know what's good for us we need to change the game. Why not incentivize savings. Do away with income tax and set up a progressive consumption tax. Say a family pulls in $1,000,000, and they save $300,000. This means that they spent $700,000 on consumables, and this is their taxable income. The tax is graduated so that low and middle income families aren't made any poorer, and also have an incentive to save. This sounds like a distributism of savings.

Despite the poor economy, we've seen another decade of little to no savings among the majority of Americans. When you think about it, we must be out of our minds.

Many reviewers complain that Frank's vision doesn't take cultural realities into account. Just because we know that intangibles are better for us doesn't mean that we can quite worshipping the invisible hand of Adam Smith. Smith told us that the sum of individuals seeking their own interest adds up to the common good for all. This is the invisible hand of the self-regulating market, but it has infected us with luxury fever. Didn't Jesus say, "Do not store up treasures on earth where moth and rust destroy and thieves break in and steal, but store up treasures in heaven where moth and rust do not destroy and thieves do not break in and steal. For where your treasure is there your heart will be also." More intangibles please!

A former student of mine described our consumer economy as a once flowing river that has all but dried up. In order to keep it flowing the government has gone into debt buying two parts hydrogen for every one part oxygen and flooding the basin of consumerism. This is an artificial stimulant that gets us spending again. But it leaves us with the hangover of buyer's regret, and a government that's going to take us down the drain with it.  I pray that this doesn't have to happen in order for us learn wisdom and change our incentives. "Righteousness exalts a nation, but sin is a reproach to any people" (Proverbs 14:34).

Saturday, December 18, 2010

Blue Empires

I've been grading a lot of papers recently about the fall of the Western Roman Empire, and it seems to me that the empire was not on the brink of social, moral, or spiritual collapse. Edward Gibbon had argued that Christianity had contributed to an otherworldliness that made the Romans militarily and economically absentminded.

The Christian Emperor Constantine however had been a life long soldier and was anything but lax militarily. He brought in a pax Romana of prosperity that rivaled that of Caesar Augustus. Peter Heather points out that the Eastern side was even more permeated with Christianity, and Constantinople thrived until the Ottoman conquest in 1453. If anything, Christianity prolonged the existence of the Western empire and then resurrected it in 800 under Charlemagne. Blood-sports did continue despite Constantine's ban. But at least such spectacle was disapproved of by the leader and the growing Christian population, who made up only about 10% of the empire at the beginning of Constantine's reign in 406.

Rome and the Western Empire fell for a myriad of reasons, which all led to a weakening of the military in the face of ever more powerful barbarian tribes who had Attila the Hun breathing down their necks. While Christianity counter-acted social factors the damage had been done and the Barbarians would not be stopped.

Romans had become self-absorbed and were no longer replacing themselves with children. Rodney Stark, in The Rise of Christianity and The Victory of Reason, documents how large families came to be seen as too costly to people's careers of political advancement and self-indulgent lifestyles (See also Peter Leithart's Defending Constantine). This despite Caesar Augustus giving tax breaks to those who made the sacrifice of bringing more than two natural born Roman citizens into the world.

Depopulation, while again counter-acted by large Christian families, left a void that the Barbarians began to fill in the fourth century, when they were hired to fight in the Roman military. This created a conflict of interest however, because barbarians sometimes found themselves fighting against their own tribes who were trying to migrate into Roman territory. Heather says that the Romans created their own conquerors by enriching them through trade and equipping them with military knowledge. It doesn't take long for the enemy to notice the hand your playing and learn to play at the same game. The weakened Romans didn't know how to counter their own military strategies and weapons when used against them.

Rome had expanded through a plunder economy which eventually ran out once the empire was so bloated it was about to pop. When they needed more money they started minting more coins. When the gold and silver started running out, they coated cheaper metals which led to hyper-inflation. The now near-sighted Romans, instead of investing in finding more mines, started hyper-taxing the provinces. When the provincials couldn't pay, the empire forced the wealthy provincials to make up the short-fall.

All this led to disgruntled population defended by an under-funded military trying to protect an over-expanded empire. Once the contractions started, the barbarians gained momentum and the rest is history: Alaric in 410, Vandals in 455, and the Foederati in 476. By the end, there was no more Western empire to occupy, and so the new barbarian ruler was given a title under the Eastern Emperor in Constantinople.    

Makes one wonder what will happen to the American Empire? At least the blue sections.

Friday, December 17, 2010

Mosaic

I've been grading a lot of position papers recently on the authorship of the Pentateuch (first five books of the Old Testament). It seems that the argument for Mosaic authorship runs thus:

The "giving" of the contents of the Pentateuch is associated with Moses, who is also described as writing specific sections. It seems likely that he would have written all of it given his education in Egypt, previous access to ancient sources, his being an eye-witness of most of the events, and a prophet who received special revelation from God. This is supported by testimony from the rest of the Old Testament and New Testament that attributes "the law," the traditional way of referring to the Pentateuch, to Moses.

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Perilous Navigation

David McCullough:

History is a guide to navigation in perilous times. History is who we are and why we are the way we are.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

All I Want For Xmas Is These Books

Just in case you were racking your brain about what to get your favorite blogger of Christmas, here's my wish list:


Why Mutants Will Never Change by Gene Poole (co-written by the Swirling Eddies)
How to Grow a Brain by Sarah Bellum (Preface by Garrison Keillor)
Don't Eat Yellow Snow by I. P. Freely (now in its 50th printing)
Under the Bleachers by Seymour Butts (now in 100 the anniversary edition)
Writing a Bestseller without Selling Out by Page Turner (Epilogue by Garrison Keillor)
Who Goosed the Moose by Antler's in the Treetops (a true classic)

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Hollywood Meets Holy Wood

There's a great article by Steven Boyer called "Narnia Invaded" over at Touchstone on the problem with the first two Narnia movies. Find it here.

Here are a few comments of my own. In Hollywood and the culture at large there can be no such thing as what Anthony Esolen calls "blessed hierarchies." When Hollywood tries to translate C. S. Lewis' Chronicles of Narnia it significantly warps the message and changes the characters. Instead a young man ready to lead, Peter is little better than Edmund at the beginning of the cinematic version of The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe. 

If you didn't know the book, I think the movie might lead you to believe that Edmund was first a victim of Peter and then the witch, instead of a kid who needed a new heart. The Peter of the movies is more conflicted than noble, and is a far cry from the chivalric knight of Lewis' imagination. 

Boyer points out that the movies have so far perverted Lewis' message to modernity into the message of modernity. Instead of the ennobling effects of duty to God-given authority, we have Edmund learning to not "do as he was told" and saving the day at the end of The Lion. Instead of his reign in Narnia teaching him to be a better leader in this world, Peter picks fights at the beginning of Prince Caspian and even with Prince Caspian, once he gets back to Narnia. The High King is anything but noble through most of the movies, because, as we post moderns know, kings by definition are self-centered tyrants. So Peter must learn to not be so kingly in the movies.

Aslan also becomes more like the god of Deism than the untame Lion who ruled at the top of the "blessed hierarchy." Mr. Beaver says, "Course he isn't safe. But he's good. He's the King, I tell you." When will we learn that we need royal priests and servant kings who know how to take orders from the King of Kings in the government, church, and families?

I'm still hoping against all odds for better from Friday's release of The Voyage of the Dawn Treader. When Hollywood meets Holy Wood the result usually leaves a lot to be desired. We shall see....

Saturday, December 4, 2010

States' Wrongs

The 150th anniversary of secession is coming up (Dec. 20), and there's a good New York Times article here about the festivities being planned. The following excerpt sums up my view of the cause of war and why, I think, the anniversary should not be celebrated:
Most historians say it is impossible to carve out slavery from the context of the war. As James W. Loewen, a liberal sociologist and author of “Lies My Teacher Told Me,” put it: “The North did not go to war to end slavery, it went to war to hold the country together and only gradually did it become anti-slavery — but slavery is why the South seceded.”

Friday, November 26, 2010

Playing Marco Polo in the Shallow End

A recent article in Christianity Today called "The Leavers: Young Doubters Exit the Church" by Drew Dyck stirred up some reflection on the state of American teenagers and another group called "emerging adults." Dyck cited the work of Christian Smith who wrote Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers. Smith documents the shallowness of the Christianity we have passed on to teens.

He characterizes the worldview of American teens as "Moralistic, therapeutic, Deism." Most teens believe that the purpose of life is to be "nice." Nice people go to heaven and "not nice" people don't. So it's moral. God created us, but he doesn't get in the way. He's there if you need him, like a therapist. Other than that, he doesn't interfere. So it's deistic.

Smith found that even kids from conservative Bible-believing churches were practically deists. I would add that if we don't show our kids the difference between Christianity and other worldviews, and why it matters, we leave them in the shallows. When deep problems begin to sink their faith, it's no wonder that they climb into someone else's boat. Dyck's article cites statistics that this is happening right now in an unprecedented way.

Smith's other work Souls in Transition: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults documents a prolonged adolescence, where young people continue to experiment morally and vocationally into their late twenties.  God may be there at the end of life, but if not, at least one has made a lot of money and been successful.

For most emerging adults, life is about having a good time and settling down "someday" with a beautiful spouse, having a couple of kids, and parties surrounded by lots of toys and friends. There's anxiety about navigating all the transitions and not messing up the future. They don't put down roots in traditional communities because they are constantly adjusting to changes.

Smith's research found that most emerging adults who attend church have no idea what their church teaches or that there's supposed to be some sort of commitment to Christ. Many go to mega-churches where nobody knows them. According to this group, dubbed "selective adherents" by Smith, church is a good thing to do on a Sunday morning as long as you don't have other plans.

Smith shows that emerging adults have little conviction about anything, even politics, because they confess to being trapped in their own subjectivity. Post modernism has made them aware that the outside world is socially constructed by the individual in his own time and place. People believe what they believe because that is how they were raised. Belief makes it true for the person, and there is no objective, shared reality to test truth claims. Live and let live for pleasure.

As a church, we've got to be more deliberate about worldview teaching and living. Christian redemption of the individual and the world for God's glory is the driving force of the Bible and redemptive history. We can know this because God has revealed it objectively and created us to know it subjectively. Our senses and our souls can reliably know the world because God made them for that purpose. Either we get into that epistemological stream or we're still playing "Marco Polo" in the shallow end.

Dyck appears to be critical of "seeker sensitive" services and "low commitment Bible Studies," of evangelical mega-churches. But in the end he says that there's nothing wrong with them as long as we also teach the faithful with more depth. I would suggest that Dyck has fallen prey to the post modern here, because everything he cited in his article militates against the low commitment approach with non-believers. This doesn't seem to jive with Jesus, who made his listeners count the cost up front. David Wells has pointed out, "What you win them with is what you win them to."

Now enter "When Scripture Becomes An A-La-Carte Menu" by James Tonkowich in By Faith. Tonkowich summarizes Smith's six categories of emerging adults:


  1. Committed Traditionalists represent approximately 15 percent of emerging adults. They “embrace a strong religious faith, whose beliefs they can reasonably well articulate and which they actively practice.”
  2. Selective Adherents (30%) believe and perform certain aspects of their religious tradition, but neglect or ignore others.” The attitude of so-called “cafeteria Catholics” is now widespread across evangelical and Reformed churches.
  3. The Spiritually Open (15%) while not committed to any specific religious faith “are nevertheless receptive to or at least mildly interested in some spiritual or religious matters.”
  4. The Religiously Indifferent (25%) don’t oppose religion, but don’t have any interest either.
  5. The Religiously Disconnected (5%) admitted to no opinions about religion because they know nothing about, and are not connected in any way, with religious bodies or friends.
  6. The Irreligious (10%) are openly hostile to all religion.
Tonkowich proceeds to a discussion of how to reach "emerging adults" who have been catechized by the culture into moral relativism. The moral relativism can be seen in the following examples cited by Tonkowich:
A man who attends a mega-church with his live-in fiancé explained to Smith why he felt comfortable ignoring his church’s teaching about pre-marital sex: “I think in my head it’s all personal opinion, whether you’re going to believe it or choose to like it and listen to it.”
“There is [a] self indulgent attitude,” ... “that says, ‘My life is difficult. I have lots of brokenness. I know it’s not right, but … .’”
Ruling Elder Bob Baldwin at GraceDC commented that when it comes to biblical sexuality, “If the rules don’t fit their cultural expectations, they mentally find a way around them, ignoring what they know to be true scripturally. What surprises me most is how carefully they have thought through their work-arounds.”
Smith documents the same pattern with the story of a young woman he interviewed: “In the middle of explaining that for religious reasons she does not believe in cohabitation before marriage, a young evangelical woman, who is devoted to gospel missionary work overseas, interrupted herself with this observation, ‘I don’t know. I think everyone is different so I don’t think [cohabitation before marriage] would work for me, but it could work for someone else.’”
Tonkowich's argues that we must reach emerging adults, especially those afflicted with moral relativism, through relationships. Tonkowich writes:
One pastor has noticed, “There are feelings of guilt, insecurity, and shame—especially shame. The problem for them is that they don’t know why these feelings exist.” In fact, these feelings hint at an authority beyond the self.
Romans 1:18-32 teaches that there are truths about life and God that we cannot not know (to use author J. Budziszewski’s phrase). We may pretend we don’t know them. We may suppress them. We may bury them under layers of carefully constructed philosophical skepticism, but all to no avail. From time to time these truths bubble uncomfortably to the surface.
Ministry to emerging adults should create opportunities founded on strong, honest relationships to explore the truths that will not be ignored, truths that explain the guilt and shame that will not go away. Apologetics begins not with correcting bad thinking, but with listening and helping to dig up the uncomfortable facts of life that, by the grace of God, will not go away.
Tonkowich collects much anecdotal evidence that opening up about struggles invites people to share honestly. Emerging adults have been programmed to "never let them see you sweat" and always exude competence. But when they see us modeling repentance then perhaps the deep end won't seem so scary.

I would add that when it comes to raising and educating children and young adults it begins with  correcting sinful ways and thinking with Bible, Bible, Bible, coupled with love deeds and modeling repentance. Constant excursions to the deep end with plenty of swimming, diving, splash fights, dunking, and laughter will build a strong Christian culture in the home that will serve them well into the future. As one pastor has noted, they will be able to "do more harm to the world than the world will be able to do to them."

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Fore Golfers

A Little More Nonsense Now and Again

A Little Nonsense Now and Then

"The Gods of the Copy Book Headings"

A friend recently shared a great piece of verse with me. Rudyard Kipling, the author of Jungle Book and "Riki Tiki Tavi," wrote the marvelous poem below.

All you need to know is that copybooks were handwriting manuals for elementary school children to hone their penmanship (a lost art). At the top were short morals and Bible verses for them to copy in their own handwriting. To understand the rest all you need is ears to hear and eyes to see.


The Gods of the Copy Book Headings:


As I pass through my incarnations in every age and race,
I make my proper prostrations to the Gods of the Market Place.
Peering through reverent fingers I watch them flourish and fall,
And the Gods of the Copybook Headings, I notice, outlast them all.


We were living in trees when they met us. They showed us each in turn
That Water would certainly wet us, as Fire would certainly burn:
But we found them lacking in Uplift, Vision and Breadth of Mind,
So we left them to teach the Gorillas while we followed the March of Mankind.


We moved as the Spirit listed. They never altered their pace,
Being neither cloud nor wind-borne like the Gods of the Market Place;
But they always caught up with our progress, and presently word would come
That a tribe had been wiped off its icefield, or the lights had gone out in Rome.


With the Hopes that our World is built on they were utterly out of touch,
They denied that the Moon was Stilton; they denied she was even Dutch;
They denied that Wishes were Horses; they denied that a Pig had Wings;
So we worshipped the Gods of the Market Who promised these beautiful things.


When the Cambrian measures were forming, They promised perpetual peace.
They swore, if we gave them our weapons, that the wars of the tribes would cease.
But when we disarmed They sold us and delivered us bound to our foe,
And the Gods of the Copybook Headings said: "Stick to the Devil you know."


On the first Feminian Sandstones we were promised the Fuller Life
(Which started by loving our neighbour and ended by loving his wife)
Till our women had no more children and the men lost reason and faith,
And the Gods of the Copybook Headings said: "The Wages of Sin is Death."


In the Carboniferous Epoch we were promised abundance for all,
By robbing selected Peter to pay for collective Paul;
But, though we had plenty of money, there was nothing our money could buy,
And the Gods of the Copybook Headings said: "If you don't work you die."


Then the Gods of the Market tumbled, and their smooth-tongued wizards withdrew
And the hearts of the meanest were humbled and began to believe it was true
That All is not Gold that Glitters, and Two and Two make Four —
And the Gods of the Copybook Headings limped up to explain it once more.


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .


As it will be in the future, it was at the birth of Man —
There are only four things certain since Social Progress began: —
That the Dog returns to his Vomit and the Sow returns to her Mire,
And the burnt Fool's bandaged finger goes wabbling back to the Fire;


And that after this is accomplished, and the brave new world begins
When all men are paid for existing and no man must pay for his sins,
As surely as Water will wet us, as surely as Fire will burn,
The Gods of the Copybook Headings with terror and slaughter return!