Showing posts with label theology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label theology. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Sunday, October 18, 2009

Doubt vs. Trust

When we doubt God, we think we know better or would do better. Given our limited nature, this is the height of arrogance. We need to trust God with his own universe.

Thursday, March 19, 2009

Free?

Augustine said something like the more we are wrapped up in God's will, the more free we are. Nietzsche said something like we cannot be free unless God is dead. 

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

The Miracle that Proves Miracles

The resurrection is the foundational miracle of the Bible. If this miracle happened, it authenticates the rest of the Bible's claims to supernatural events and revealed doctrine. Tim Keller says that when someone tells him that they struggle with some part of Christian teaching he usually responds by saying:
If Jesus rose from the dead, then you have to accept all he said; if he didn't rise from the dead, then why worry about any of what he said... That is how the first hearers felt who heard reports of the resurrection. They knew that if it was true it meant we can't live our lives any way we want. It also meant we don't have to be afraid of anything, not Roman swords, not cancer, nothing. If Jesus rose from the dead, it changes everything (The Reason for God, 202).

Other myths have stories of dying and rising gods like Balder, Osiris, and Isis, but they are mere myths. Christianity is myth but not mere myth. It is, as C.S. Lewis said, "myth made fact" or the true myth. The difference is that Christian myth actually happened in time and space history. Jesus was born under Caesar Augustus and crucified under Pontius Pilate and the disciples talk about:
That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked at and our hands have touched—this we proclaim concerning the Word of life. 2The life appeared; we have seen it and testify to it, and we proclaim to you the eternal life, which was with the Father and has appeared to us. 3We proclaim to you what we have seen and heard, so that you also may have fellowship with us. And our fellowship is with the Father and with his Son, Jesus Christ. (1 John 1:1-3)

When unbelievers say that Christianity only borrowed its mythology from earlier pagan stories, the proper response is to smile and say no, Christianity fulfilled them.

Wednesday, February 4, 2009

Skepticism vs. Reason

The skeptic says faith and reason are in conflict, but skepticism is actually in conflict with reason. If skepticism calls everything into question it must also call itself and reason into question. Otherwise, the skeptic must admit that he accepts reason by faith.

We must all believe things that we cannot prove. If we would apply skepticism to everything we would never get anywhere. If we apply skepticism to itself it crumbles. Reason needs a foundation to build upon. All of us must simply accept a starting point and build on that foundation. If the foundation is weak we can replace it or strengthen it, but we can never work without one.

Credo ut intelligam. I believe in order that I might understand.

Penn Jillete on Proselytizing

Tuesday, February 3, 2009

Custom and Creed

This man's spiritual power has been precisely this: that he has distinguished between custom and creed. He has broken the conventions, but he has kept the commandments.
G. K. chesterton Manalive


This is the wisdom of Jesus who offended so many but who was beloved by his Father. James tells us that the Lord gives wisdom to any who ask without finding fault. O' to be loved by the Father!

Sunday, February 1, 2009

Pre-marital Expectation

"Unhappy! Of course you'll be unhappy! Who the devil are you that you shouldn't be unhappy, like the mother that bore you? Disappointed! Of course we'll be disappointed! I, for one, don't expect till I die to be so good a man as I am at this minute, for just now I'm fifty thousand feet high, a tower with all the trumpets shouting."

"You see all this," said Rosamund, with a grand sincerity in her solid face, "and do you really want to marry me?"

"My darling, what else is there to do?" reasoned the Irishman. "What other occupation is there for an active man on this earth, except to marry you? What's the alternative to marriage, barring sleep? It's not liberty, Rosamund. Unless you marry God, as our nuns do in Ireland, you must marry Man; that is Me. The only third thing is to marry yourself-to live with yourself, yourself, yourself-the only companion that is never satisfied-and never satisfactory."

"Michael," said Miss Hunt, in a very soft voice, "if you won't talk so much, I'll marry you."

"It's no time for talking," cried Micahel Moon. "Singing is the only thing. Can't you find that mandoline of yours, Rosamund?"

"Go and fetch it for me," said Rosamund, with crisp and sharp authority.
G. K. Chesterton Manalive


Life is a thing to be risked, and that's grace!

Thursday, January 29, 2009

The Method of Madness

Madness does not come by breaking out, but by giving in; by settling down in some dirty, self-repeating circle of ideas; by being tamed.
G. K. Chesterton, Manalive

Chesterton's thesis seems to be that by forgetting the self, we can become our true selves. Jesus said: "Whoever would find his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for my sake finds it." Jesus also asserted: "unless you change and become like little children, you will never enter the kingdom of heaven." We have to stay children to stay sane.

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

The Problem with Biotechnology

The problem with biotechnology is that we are playing with God's power without having his knowledge.

Sunday, January 25, 2009

Creation Days Controversy

This morning in Sunday School I heard a great summary of John C. Collins exegesis of the nature of the creation days. Collins believes in verbal, plenary (full) inspiration of Scripture, and in literal or authorial intent interpretation of the Bible. Collins also believes that the creation days of Genesis 1 are not 24 hour solar days but our 24 hour solar days are analogical to the days of creation.  Dr. Collins is a former prof of mine at Covenant seminary and I had heard his argument before but this crystallized it for me. The basic argument runs as follows:

  1. The Hebrew word for day "yom" is not a technical term for a 24 hour solar day. Genesis 2:4 refers to the entire week of creation as a "yom."
  2. We are still in the seventh day. The refrain "evening and morning" occurs at the end of each creation day and refers to the period of rest between the periods of work. This refrain does not occur on the seventh day, which shows that God is still at rest. Thus the seventh day is ongoing and not a 24 hour solar day. Hebrews 4:3-5 confirms this interpretation saying that "God rested on the seventh day from his all works" but disobedient Israel cannot enter his rest. Augustine, who was obviously not trying to make peace with Darwinism, pointed this out in his Confessions. He said that since God is still in his seventh day we can enter his rest by faith. 
  3. God's creation days are analogical. They set the pattern for our 24 hour solar days. Since God rested the "evening and morning" of each day so should we. Since God rested on the seventh day so should we. Just like our creating is based on God's creating without being ex nihilo (out of nothing), so our days are like his without his necessarily being 24 hours long.
  4. The best way to harmonize Genesis 1 and 2 is to assume the days of Genesis 1 are analogical. It is hard to imagine Adam getting lonely within the first day given all the work he had to do tending the garden and naming the animals.

Saturday, January 17, 2009

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Comparative Religion

Jesus made comparative religion easy when he claimed to be God. No other religion claims that their founder claimed this. DeSouza has pointed out that this boils everything down to two kinds of religion: one says God descended to man because man cannot save himself, all others say man must ascend to God to save himself. The question isn't which religion is true, but whether Jesus is who he claimed to be. Peter Kreeft puts it well when he calls him the "cosmic touchstone."

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Nature and Grace in the Public Space


Our Headmaster, Chris Baker, gave a lecture today and spoke about how modern secularism has separated nature and grace. He went on to enumerate the consequences in art, architecture, and music. My class and I saw the fragmentation that has resulted but also a kind of broken beauty that peaks through and resonates at times with the glorious ruin that we are. He also showed the stark contrast between modern art and that of the Renaissance, which still largely retained clear delineating lines, order, and realism.

This led me to think about the relationship between nature and grace. Since the fall we have been in dire need of special grace for salvation while a common grace, where God "sends rain on the just and the unjust," has continued to preserve us despite periods of terrible drought. There is also drought that cracks the cultural landscape, when we, as a society, lose touch with special and common grace. Nature here does not refer merely to the natural world of rocks, trees, and animals but all of creation including human nature and culture. Nature is what is natural as distinct from grace which is supernatural. Grace replenishes and rectifies nature so that we can envision its redemption. But when we try to isolate nature from grace in order to secularize society, we end up with ugly consequences.

Chris pointed out that when we began to lose God's input in art, images of man and landscapes began to smudge. Clear lines blurred and we were left with impressions, surreal bits and pieces, mere cubes, expressions of painful interior experiences, and even machine like depictions of man.

Let me paraphrase Chesterton: The separation of nature and grace does not leave us with the natural but with the unnatural. O' Lord give us grace in our personal lives that we may transmit it to a society in need of you.

Sunday, January 11, 2009

Unfree Choice?

I've recently been translating Luther's De servo arbitrio (The Bondage of the Will) and thought I'd take a stab at restating Luther's thesis.

There’s no free choice since everything happens by God’s foreordination ultimately and all human choices are bound either to sin or grace. The will, however, may be said to be free in the sense of voluntary and in having ability over created things which are below man (like his possessions). The will may also be said to be free when grace brings "royal freedom" to do what is right.

Saturday, January 10, 2009

Can We Say "Good" without God?

I've been watching the Hitchens and Wilson debate at Westminster Seminary, Philadelphia (click on title for the link). Wilson says there's no way to call anything true, good, or beautiful without God. Then Hitchens goes on explaining how atheists and people with no religious confession have produced some of the truest, most ethical, and beautiful cultural goods.

It seems to me that we're not saying atheists can't produce objects of the most magnificent beauty, but that there's no way to call them beautiful unless God exists. Anytime we say, "That's beautiful," about a sunset, we're not just appealing to our own subjective sense of beauty. We are also appealing to an objective standard of beauty beyond ourselves. There is a beauty behind all other beauties that makes beauty a coherent concept common to all people.

But what about when people disagree over whether the sunset is beautiful. Well most people agree on sunsets, but when we're talking about a cloudy, cold, winter day or a piece of modern art, we appeal to that God defined beauty when we argue that the day has its own kind of barren beauty or the piece of art is beautiful or not.

When we call something ugly we also appeal to an objective standard that has been violated. When we say Hitler was wrong we assume a moral standard beyond our feelings to which he was accountable. To paraphrase Lewis, we can't posit evil in the world unless we posit an object standard of good beyond the world.   

Thursday, December 18, 2008

Grasping for Truth


I recently finished Is Christianity Good For the World, which is the debate between atheist Christopher Hitchens and theologian Doug Wilson. On the heat to light ratio it scored well on both counts. They are both great polemicists and so there's enough heat to warm the cockles of your heart. They are also clear thinkers so they, especially Wilson, illuminates the fundamental difference between atheism and Christianity.

In fact, I think Hitchens was put a little off his guard by Wilsons' insistence that he provide an atheistic basis for the distinction between good and evil. I've seen Hitchens debate McGrath and DeSouza and, going by that, I think he expected an evidence war on his own turf. Instead, Wilson took the epistemic ground and made Hitchens fight for the right to call something evil or good. 

Wilson also made the point that without God there's no basis for faith in reason or sense experience. Notice that I used the word "faith." Hitchens doesn't want to admit that his position is equally faith-based. He continually goes back to the position that morality is innate and worked out by trial and error as humans attempt to build a coherent, law-abiding civilization. But this begs the question: Why, if morality is a product of the careless process of evolution, do humans care for coherence or law or beauty for that matter? Why aren't we just content with what is? If evolution were the only reality it could not produce any ideals higher than what is. Wilson says to Hitchens:

Your notion of morality, and the evolution it rode in on, can only concern itself with what is. But morality as Christians understand it, and the kind you surreptitiously draw upon, is concerned with ought. David Hume showed us that we cannot successfully derive ought from is. Have you discovered the error in his reasoning? It is clear from how you defend your ideas of 'morality' that you have not done so.... You believe yourself to live in a universe where there is no such thing as any fixed ought or ought not. But God has gifted you with a remarkable ability to denounce what ought not to be.
Hitchen's is living off borrowed capital any time he denounces anything. If he denounces tyranny, which he often does, he appeals a higher moral law than himself to which the tyrant is accountable. He assumes a moral law that binds himself and the tyrant and all of humanity together. He also assumes that the tyrant has transgressed it and must receive his just desserts. 

But if Hitchen's is right about there being no creator or revealer of right and wrong, then right and wrong is only what Hitchens thinks it is. And whatever Hitchens thinks is right or wrong, cannot be binding on anyone else. As Dostoevsky said: "If God is dead, all things are permissible." Hitchens seems to miss the fact that there can be no right and wrong if there is no standard for right and wrong.

Wilson's reference to Hume's point that "we cannot successfully derive ought from is" is telling for Hitchens. If Hume and Hitchen's worldview is correct there would be no way to tell someone they ought to do something (like help an old lady across the street) because of what is the case (she's old). But the fact that Hitchens and Hume do this kind of thing, shows that they cannot live consistently within their own worldview. In fact, Hume is saying that it is the case that you ought not derive an ought from an is. The philosophy is self-defeating and this is Wilson's point that Hitchens hasn't yet grapsed.

Sunday, December 14, 2008

Questioning God at Christmas


At family worship the other night we read the passage where an angel visited Zechariah and told him that he and his wife were going to have a son. The text says, "They had no child, because Elizabeth was barren, and both were well advanced in years" (v. 7). Zechariah was a priest and offering incense in the temple when the angel appeared. The Angel Gabriel told Zechariah not to be afraid "for your prayer has been heard, and your wife Elizabeth will bear you a son, and you shall call his name John" (v. 13). Zechariah replied, "How shall I know this? For I am an old man, and my wife is well advanced in years."

When Gabriel visited Mary not long after, announcing that she would conceive the "the Son of the Most HIgh," who would reign on "the throne of his father David" and "over the house of Jacob forever," she asked, "How will this be, since I am a virgin?" Gabriel told Mary that "the Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the most High will overshadow you; therefore the child ... will be called ... the Son of God." In contrast, Gabriel struck Zechariah's mute button, so that he could not speak until John was born.

Then my son Jonathan said "Why did God punish one and not the other for questioning the angel?" "Great question" said I, scrambling a bit, "what's the difference?" He just looked at me, so I said, well, Mary sounds like she believes the angel but she wants to know how God will do it. She says, "How will this be since I am a virgin." But Zechariah says, "How shall I know this," which means ... then Jonathan said, "He wanted a sign!" "Right!" said I. His was a question of unbelief while Mary's was a question of faith. Gabriel told Zechariah, the trained theologian, "you will be ... unable to speak ... because you did not believe." When Mary heard Gabriel's response she said, "Behold, I am the servant of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word."

Zechariah should have known that God was in the baby business for old barren couples (the BBOBC) since this happened to Abraham and Sarah in one of the most memorable stories of the Old Testament that led to the creation of Israel itself. Zechariah must have been praying for this as well (at least at some point in his life) because Gabriel said " your prayer has been answered." Isn't it funny that we cannot accept it when God answers our prayers. It's too good to be true! 

Speaking of funny, I said to Jonathan that Zechariah was basically asking for a sign in the presence of an archangel! To which we both started laughing. Five year old Kate already knew this story and had been participating the whole way. She immediately piped up and demanded that we stop laughing. I said, "That's OK sweetie. Zechariah probably laughed about it later, 'Can you believe I asked for a sign and the angel was standing right there'!" :-)

We should let Mary teach us how to question God, not Zechariah and not the unbelieving world. Faith is a better questioner anyway, because faith seeketh understanding (credo ut intelligam) and unbelief just wants to look clever or wants off the hook. Praise the Lord that Zechariah learned his lesson. Mightn't we?

Saturday, December 6, 2008

C. S. Lewis on G. K. Chesterton & the Charm of Goodness



When a yet unconverted Lewis was convalescing after a WWI battle wound he says:

It was here that I first read a volume of Chesterton's essays. I had no idea of what he stood for; nor can I quite understand why he made such an immediate conquest of me. It might have been expected that my pessimism, my atheism, and my hatred of sentiment would have made him to me the least congenial of all authors. It would alomost seem that Providence, or some "second cause" of a very obscure kind, quited overrules our previous tastes when it decides to bring two minds together. ... I did not need to accept what Chesterton said in order to enjoy it. His humor was of the kind which I like best--not "jokes" imbedded in the page like currants in a cake, still less (what I cannot endure), a general tone of flippancy and jocularity, but the humor which is not in any way separable from the argument but is rahter (as Aristotle would say) the "bloom" on dialectic itself. The sword glitters not because the swordsman set out to make it glitter but because he is fighting for his life and therfore moving it very quickly. For the critics who think Chesterton frivolous or "paradoxical" I have to work hard to feel even pity; sympathy is out of the question. Moreover, strange as it may seem, I liked him for his goodness. ... In reading Chesterton, as in reading MacDonald, I did not know what I was letting myself in for. A young man who wishes to temain a sound Atheist cannot be too careful of his reading. There are traps everywhere--"Bibles laid open, millions of surprises," as Herbert says, "fine nets and stratagems." God is, if I may say it, very unscrupulous (Surprised by Joy, Harvest, Harcourt, 190-191).

I think we should talk more about the seductiveness of holiness. Enjoying goodness makes one feel clean. Once your soul cultivates a taste for that, victory over sin leaves no regret over cheap pleasures missed. We must remember that it is the "kindness of God" that leads us "to repentance" (Romans 2:4).